F-20:
    title: Tested plant-label and repeated-label cribs show no supported text link
    superseded_title: "There is no internal crib (narrowed 2026-10-19 by reviewer, D-082 e: it exceeded the tested pharma-label/herbal-page and repeated-label questions)"
    statement: Pharma sketches match their herbal partners in images, but their labels share no text with the partner page, though the test finds a planted link.
    map: [dot13]
    claims: [c-371, c-377, c-388, c-389]
    status: standing
    lines:
      - {axis: method, by: "s48 image embeddings, s53 part-level matching", ref: results_s53.txt, claim: c-388, agrees: true}
      - {axis: impl, by: "Argon s53 text-side labels", ref: results_s53_p4a1_p4e1_anchors_and_errors.txt, claim: c-377, agrees: true, unverified: true, note: "INPUT ERROR found 2026-10-19 (Astra source check runs/explore/plant_group_sourcecheck_20261019 in yonichmanuscript; reconciled by Opus against data/external/page-facts/plants and eyecheck/pairs.tsv): 8 of 12 ZL_PHARMA_HERBAL_PAIRS in s53_p4a1_p4e1_anchors_and_errors.py name the wrong pharma page (f3v unsourced; f19r, f32v, f47v, f48r, f90v1, f90v2, f96v point to pages no source gives). Part 1 label tests stop counting; s54 (correct ZL cell list) and s128 (18 eye-checked published pairs) carry the finding"}
      - {axis: data, by: "3 transliterations and whole-word/core-stem variants", ref: results_s53_p4a1_p4e1_anchors_and_errors.txt, claim: c-377, agrees: true, unverified: true, note: "INPUT ERROR found 2026-10-19 (Astra source check runs/explore/plant_group_sourcecheck_20261019 in yonichmanuscript; reconciled by Opus against data/external/page-facts/plants and eyecheck/pairs.tsv): 8 of 12 ZL_PHARMA_HERBAL_PAIRS in s53_p4a1_p4e1_anchors_and_errors.py name the wrong pharma page (f3v unsourced; f19r, f32v, f47v, f48r, f90v1, f90v2, f96v point to pages no source gives). Part 1 label tests stop counting; s54 (correct ZL cell list) and s128 (18 eye-checked published pairs) carry the finding"}
      - {axis: external, by: "Daybreak db-s114 (own code, no imports from this tree): Stolfi 1998 label catalogue, 239 loci, 27 repeated types; repeated labels agree on plant/root/container class 20/31 = null median (p 0.63); ghost-row correction (rev2 stub 5/5, rerun byte-identical, audit-external-B 2026-10-18): 6/15, p 0.745; independence of 14/15 remaining pairs unverified (catalogue .X. positions)", ref: <lab>/codex_lab/experiments/results_s114_repeated_label_object_consistency.txt, agrees: true}
      - {axis: external, by: "s128-p72: published human matches (Zandbergen/Stolfi/Petersen), eye-checked, 18 pairs; NO_LINK p 0.72 at power 0.958; Egerton control 200/200", ref: results_s128_20261019T090659.txt, claim: c-590, agrees: true}
    controls:
      - {what: "s115-A0: the s48/s53 image-retrieval test recovers real same-name partners in captioned herbals at Voynich size (power 0.995; Voynich 3/13 top-5 vs real median 7/13)", ref: results_s115_a0_20261018T203952.txt, matched: true}
      - {what: "planted label-text link recovered", ref: results_s54.txt, matched: true}
    points:
      - {h: H-06, rel: against, strength: weak, why: "a labelling text would share label words with its page"}
    decisions: [D-053]